Writing Literature Reviews

Charles, C. C.

Download

HTML can be useful for transferring content to other online publishing platforms, typically by copy/pasting to the new platform.

<p id="p_TeFJ" name="p_TeFJ" class=""><img src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_1.jpg" class="img-fluid col-12" alt="English315-SocialSciences-12.jpg" id="img_butH" name="img_butH"></p><ul id="ul_GnxR" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="8e6fk-0-0" name="ul_GnxR"></ul><div class="callout default" data-callout-custom-class="default">
<h3 id="h3_aoUM" name="h3_aoUM" class="">Learning Outcomes</h3>
<div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="1n88h" data-offset-key="b1nec-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="b1nec-0-0"><span data-offset-key="b1nec-0-0" class=""> In this chapter, you'll learn the steps to creating a literature review including </span></div>
</div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="8a79c-0-0">
<ul id="ul_CBvE" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="8pr2g-0-0" name="ul_CBvE"><li id="li_yHdQ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="begc8" data-offset-key="8pr2g-0-0" name="li_yHdQ">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="8pr2g-0-0"><span data-offset-key="8pr2g-0-0" class="">writing an introduction, body paragraphs, a discussion/conclusion, abstract, and other elements</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_KLtI" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="begc8" data-offset-key="s6ff-0-0" name="li_KLtI">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="s6ff-0-0"><span data-offset-key="s6ff-0-0" class="">drafting and getting feedback</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_baMW" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="begc8" data-offset-key="1oion-0-0" name="li_baMW">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="1oion-0-0"><span data-offset-key="1oion-0-0" class="">revising your literature review</span></div>
</li>
</ul></div>
</div><p id="p_Vjqy" name="p_Vjqy" class=""><strong class="">Note: Because this chapter involves the steps for writing your Literature Review, the discussion questions in each section will be more involved than in other chapters, so give yourself extra time. But never fear! They will all lead to writing a better paper.</strong></p><p id="p_CzGP" name="p_CzGP" class=""></p><h2 id="p_AQEI" name="p_AQEI" class="">12.1 Draft and Synthesize</h2><p id="p_hyBw" name="p_hyBw" class="">First, I want you to watch this 10-minute video because it both reviews what we talked about in the last chapter and provides great ways to get started on the actual writing of your paper. Here are some highlights to pay attention to: </p><ul id="ul_ufax" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="5c8qs-0-0" name="ul_ufax"><li id="li_xnds" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="5c8qs-0-0" name="li_xnds">
<p id="p_KGgn" name="p_KGgn" class="">questions to ask as you take or review your notes that will guide your writing</p>
</li>
<li id="li_mIhf" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="e5sat-0-0" name="li_mIhf">
<p id="p_gydM" name="p_gydM" class="">suggestions for how to organize your notes. (Or actually, I should spell it "organise" with an "s" since the video comes from Australia.)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_WxhZ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="9a3lk-0-0" name="li_WxhZ">
<p id="p_xzad" name="p_xzad" class="">ways to add interpretation to what you say about your sources</p>
</li>
<li id="li_aDJY" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="bjeej-0-0" name="li_aDJY">
<p id="p_zzTb" name="p_zzTb" class="">language to use to comment on the studies you're summarizing and synthesizing</p>
</li>
<li id="li_AKYU" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="8nb2f-0-0" name="li_AKYU">
<p id="p_YARy" name="p_YARy" class="">examples of literature review synthesis</p>
</li>
</ul><figure class="image"><div class="youtube-container" data-bs-toggle="modal" data-src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/70n2-gAp7J0?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" data-bs-target="#youtube-modal"><img class="img-fluid col-12" src="https://img.youtube.com/vi/70n2-gAp7J0/maxresdefault.jpg" data-youtube-id="70n2-gAp7J0" id="img_kLwh" name="img_kLwh" data-youtube-id="70n2-gAp7J0" src-ok="1" alt="Image preview of a YouTube video"><div class="youtube-overlay"><img src="https://open.byu.edu/images/youtube-icon.png" alt="" id="img_FJAJ" name="img_FJAJ" class=""></div></div><a href="https://www.youtube.com/embed/70n2-gAp7J0?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" target="_blank" class="d-block text-center youtube-link" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-WFP" data-unshortened-url="https://www.youtube.com/embed/70n2-gAp7J0?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1"><small class="text-muted">Watch on YouTube <span class="display-url pdf-only">https://open.byu.edu/-WFP</span></small></a><figcaption class="">https://youtu.be/70n2-gAp7J0</figcaption></figure><div class="callout">
<p id="p_YFDZ" name="p_YFDZ" class=""><strong class="">Video Review</strong></p>
<p id="p_zqLk" name="p_zqLk" class="">What three strategies or elements from the video do you plan to incorporate into your own Literature Review?</p>
</div><h3 id="p_zbmy" name="p_zbmy" class=""><strong class="">Start Drafting</strong></h3><p id="p_WpWq" name="p_WpWq" class="">Now it's time to start drafting your paper. Follow the structure from your outline and start filling in the missing parts. Get out your notes and remind yourself of the sources you plan to talk about. You don't have to write your paper from beginning to end in order—you can go to the parts that feel the easiest and start there. Here are some places you can start:</p><h4 id="p_kwJH" name="p_kwJH" class=""><strong class="">Bullet-Point Draft</strong></h4><p id="p_srZD" name="p_srZD" class=""></p><p id="p_NIkB" name="p_NIkB" class=""><img class="Imagestyles__StyledImage-sc-1m2aclr-6 iUaPeZ" alt="fikri-rasyid-491597-unsplash.jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_2.jpg" id="img_BYzM" name="img_BYzM"></p><p id="p_jGcK" name="p_jGcK" class="">Writing your Bullet Points should be as fast as this Bullet Train. Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@fikrirasyid" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-EBJP" data-unshortened-url="https://unsplash.com/@fikrirasyid">Fikri Rasyid</a> on Unsplash</p><p id="p_KJjt" name="p_KJjt" class="">I often have my students start with a Bullet-Point draft that takes the ideas they've been outlining and fills them in with more details but only in bullet-point form. The beauty of bullet points is that they keep you from getting caught up in the language and style and allow you to focus simply on your main points. You can smooth out the sentences and transitions later, but for now, just get your ideas on the page.</p><h4 id="p_ZeZU" name="p_ZeZU" class=""><strong class="">Write the Introduction</strong></h4><p id="p_CEya" name="p_CEya" class="">Another way to get started is to just write the Introduction. You already have a thesis statement that can go at the end, so now you can start introducing your topic and its importance, setting up your Literature Review. See below for more specific help with Introductions.</p><h4 id="p_qqXd" name="p_qqXd" class=""><strong class="">Write a Body Paragraph</strong></h4><p id="p_tsMK" name="p_tsMK" class="">Or a third place to start is to jump into writing a body paragraph that synthesizes your sources—the way you did in that synthesis activity earlier. Take your notes and choose one set to talk about in paragraph form.</p><p id="p_JMox" name="p_JMox" class="">Don't think too hard about getting things perfect when you're drafting—that's what revision is for. Just focus on getting started and filling in some of the missing pieces. If you get stuck, do some brainstorming activities to get your creative juices flowing. Once you have something written, I suggest seeking feedback to make sure you're going in the right direction. In fact, I recommend getting as much feedback as possible along the way.</p><div class="callout default" data-callout-custom-class="default">
<h3 id="h3_ucHuG" name="h3_ucHuG" class="">Start Writing</h3>
<p id="p_tGXXw" name="p_tGXXw" class="">Now it's your turn to choose somewhere to start writing—choose either a bullet-point draft, the introduction, a body paragraph or something else. Then write the equivalent of at least one paragraph.</p>
</div><div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="5mtad-0-0"> </div><h3 id="h3_rxXB" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="5mtad-0-0" name="h3_rxXB"><span data-offset-key="5mtad-0-0" class="">How to Write Each Section</span></h3><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="2cb88-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="2cb88-0-0"><span data-offset-key="2cb88-0-0" class="">Now that you've jump-started the writing process, we'll go through each of the parts of your paper more in depth to help you fill out a complete draft.</span></div>
</div><h3 id="h3_VjSj" name="h3_VjSj" class="">Introduction</h3><p id="p_rHzu" name="p_rHzu" class="">Once you know what your main points will be, you're ready to introduce your ideas. As in any paper, you can't just jump right into your thesis statement and points; you need to set the stage first. Here are the elements of a good introduction to a literature review:</p><p id="p_hBnN" name="p_hBnN" class="">A good introduction</p><ul id="ul_AHPg" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="edb67-0-0" name="ul_AHPg"><li id="li_RwyQ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="edb67-0-0" name="li_RwyQ">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="edb67-0-0"><span data-offset-key="edb67-0-0" class="">introduces the topic and indicates its importance (impact on individuals)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_rdtj" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="bqtju-0-0" name="li_rdtj">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="bqtju-0-0"><span data-offset-key="bqtju-0-0" class="">gives a context for the research question</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_CGus" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="bvbur-0-0" name="li_CGus">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="bvbur-0-0"><span data-offset-key="bvbur-0-0" class="">defines key terms, concepts, and/or theories</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_yPgI" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="2pd24-0-0" name="li_yPgI">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="2pd24-0-0"><span data-offset-key="2pd24-0-0" class="">explains what search methods were used and how many and what types of sources were reviewed (this is sometimes optional)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_LPbc" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="44o7l-0-0" name="li_LPbc">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="44o7l-0-0"><span data-offset-key="44o7l-0-0" class="">suggests the organization of the rest of the paper</span></div>
</li>
</ul><p id="p_KZBb" name="p_KZBb" class=""><span data-offset-key="81n22-0-0" class="">Remember in some style guides like the </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-YhB" data-unshortened-url="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/"><span data-offset-key="81n22-1-0" class="">APA Manual</span></a><span data-offset-key="81n22-2-0" class="">, you don't need to title your Introduction "Introduction"—you simply center the title of your paper at the top of your page (bolded and in title capitalization format) and then jump right into your first paragraph. </span></p><p id="p_Gqmqq" name="p_Gqmqq" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" class="">Tip: You don't always know where you're going when you start a paper, so just get a good draft of an introduction down. Then when you finish writing a first draft of your paper, read your conclusion and consider using some of it in your introduction instead. I often tell my students that conclusions make good introductions because you finally know exactly where you went in your paper. Either way, you'll want to revisit your introduction once your paper's done so you can adjust it to better match where your paper went.</span></p><div class="callout">
<h3 id="p_CJCi" name="p_CJCi" class=""><strong class="">Introduction</strong></h3>
<p id="p_kFQL" name="p_kFQL" class="">Get a start on your introduction by writing an opening sentence that introduces your topic and/or indicates its importance. Then you can use that to jump start the rest of your introduction.</p>
</div><h3 id="p_jKAI" name="p_jKAI" class=""><strong class="">Body</strong></h3><p id="p_rsRm" name="p_rsRm" class=""><span data-offset-key="3fuk0-0-0" class="">The <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="body">body</span> of your paper is where you can develop your points and use your newfound synthesis skills. Remember the </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://edtechbooks.org/writing/plan_lit_review" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-Xkgy" data-unshortened-url="https://edtechbooks.org/writing/plan_lit_review"><span data-offset-key="3fuk0-1-0" class="">synthesis activity with the videos</span></a><span data-offset-key="3fuk0-2-0" class=""> you did in the last chapter? As you create a draft, you can start composing paragraphs using your awesome notes just like you practiced with those videos. Try to incorporate several sources into each paragraph to be sure that you're synthesizing and not just summarizing or listing without making connections. Your color-coded notes can help you be sure that each paragraph contains multiple sources.</span></p><p id="p_ZTaj" name="p_ZTaj" class="">In the body of your paper, you should</p><ul id="ul_NdFx" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="6i57o-0-0" name="ul_NdFx"><li id="li_hQnu" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="6i57o-0-0" name="li_hQnu">
<p id="p_syXc" name="p_syXc" class="">synthesize previous studies to inform the reader of the state of research</p>
</li>
<li id="li_GvBq" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="i034-0-0" name="li_GvBq">
<p id="p_yyef" name="p_yyef" class="">“identify relations, contradictions, gaps, and inconsistencies in the literature” (<a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-YhB" data-unshortened-url="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/"><em class="">APA Manual</em></a>, p. 8)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_bwoI" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="8ugkf-0-0" name="li_bwoI">
<p id="p_zAUc" name="p_zAUc" class="">group your points into major headings and subheadings (You choose the arrangement based on what you’ve found: similar concepts or theories, similar methods, chronological development, controversies, etc.)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_fKAm" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="7r3cr-0-0" name="li_fKAm">
<p id="p_kwmf" name="p_kwmf" class="">support all points with sound reasoning or evidence drawn from sources and in which all borrowed information is documented</p>
</li>
<li id="li_NutP" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="ehd76-0-0" name="li_NutP">
<p id="p_fdqq" name="p_fdqq" class="">summarize sources most of the time, paraphrase sometimes, and use quotations very sparingly—only when specific wording is poignant or can’t be said in any other way.</p>
</li>
</ul><p id="p_NRYb" name="p_NRYb" class="">One way to talk about your sources is known as the CEC Method: Claim-Evidence-Commentary.</p><blockquote class="" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="b1umm-0-0">
<p id="p_nKum" name="p_nKum" class="">Claim + Evidence + Commentary</p>
</blockquote><p id="p_DuwW" name="p_DuwW" class="">Just like any paragraph, you should start with a Topic sentence that acts as a mini-Thesis statement or a general <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="claim">claim</span> about your topic. Then you need to give <strong class="">evidence</strong> to support that claim. In a literature review, your evidence comes in the form of studies that have been done—all those brilliant notes you've been taking. This is where you can synthesize your sources and show that they are related under the umbrella of a topic. However, just listing or summarizing sources does not make the connection between them and your topic sentence clear. This is where <strong class="">commentary</strong> comes in. Your job is also to comment on and interpret the significance of your "evidence" so your audience can understand the connections between them. In synthesis, your language is the key.</p><p id="p_kuSU" name="p_kuSU" class="">In the next chapter, we'll talk more about how to do this, especially how to incorporate <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="metacommentary">metacommentary</span> into your paragraphs.</p><h4 id="p_BRGh" name="p_BRGh" class=""><strong class="">Add Metacommentary</strong></h4><p id="p_TQBv" name="p_TQBv" class="">Metacommentary is the key to synthesis. <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="metacommentary">metacommentary</span> (aka metadiscourse) is a type of commentary that guides your reader and helps them interpret the sources and evidence you're presenting. Think of it as really powerful transitions. First, let's remind ourselves what <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="transitions">transitions</span> are. Transition words act like signposts—they guide your reader through your points. They can also glue your ideas together so they feel more cohesive. Beware that transitions can definitely be overdone, but I'd say most students in general could use more transitions in their papers rather than fewer.</p><figure class="image"><img class="col-12 float-md-end col-md-6 mb-md-2 me-md-0 ms-md-3" alt="202089464_760e31f318_m.jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_3.jpg" id="img_qHDd" name="img_qHDd"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="c88mt-0-0" class="">Add signposts to your writing to guide your reader. Photo by </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/70205452@N00/202089609" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-AfpB" data-unshortened-url="https://www.flickr.com/photos/70205452@N00/202089609"><span data-offset-key="c88mt-1-0" class="">Dallas</span></a><span data-offset-key="c88mt-2-0" class=""> on Flickr.</span></figcaption></figure><p id="p_zXaf" name="p_zXaf" class=""></p><p id="p_ygmMs" name="p_ygmMs" class="">Here's an awesome <a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/engagement/ged_preparation/part_1_lessons_1_4/transitions.html" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-xpEK" data-unshortened-url="https://owl.purdue.edu/engagement/ged_preparation/part_1_lessons_1_4/transitions.html">list of transition words</a> (also linked in the frame below) that are grouped by category from the famous Purdue OWL (Online Writing Lab—scroll down to see the list). <span data-offset-key="eq6t5-2-0" class="">You can also download a great handout from the University of Maryland </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://www.umaryland.edu/media/umb/oaa/campus-life/writing-center/documents/Transitions.pdf" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-wzm" data-unshortened-url="https://www.umaryland.edu/media/umb/oaa/campus-life/writing-center/documents/Transitions.pdf"><span data-offset-key="eq6t5-3-0" class="">here</span></a><span data-offset-key="eq6t5-4-0" class="">. </span></p><p id="p_IWtR" name="p_IWtR" class="">I always suggest that my students keep a categorized transition list like this handy as they write so that when they know they want to connect ideas in a certain way (e.g. to show contrast), you can easily find a good list of options (e.g. in contrast, conversely, etc.). Not only will transitions help your ideas feel more connected, they will also smooth out your writing style like butter.</p><p id="p_NcdZ" name="p_NcdZ" class=""></p><p id="p_Sjgs" name="p_Sjgs" class=""><iframe class="Iframestyles__Iframe-accts1-2 gjjnFa" style="width: 100%; height: 400px;" src="https://owl.purdue.edu/engagement/ged_preparation/part_1_lessons_1_4/transitions.html" data-mce-fragment="1"></iframe></p><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="8vhld-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="8vhld-0-0"><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://owl.purdue.edu/engagement/ged_preparation/part_1_lessons_1_4/transitions.html" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-xpEK" data-unshortened-url="https://owl.purdue.edu/engagement/ged_preparation/part_1_lessons_1_4/transitions.html">https://open.byu.edu/-xpEK</a></div>
</div><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="a3as9-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="a3as9-0-0"><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://www.umaryland.edu/media/umb/oaa/campus-life/writing-center/documents/Transitions.pdf" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-wzm" data-unshortened-url="https://www.umaryland.edu/media/umb/oaa/campus-life/writing-center/documents/Transitions.pdf">https://open.byu.edu/-wzm</a></div>
</div><p id="p_hhxV" name="p_hhxV" class="">You might think you can just stop at transition words, but metacommentary is much more than just sprinkling some "therefores" and "howevers" throughout your paper—metacommentary actually takes your synthesis to the next level. Remember the Claim-Evidence-Commentary pattern I've mentioned? The commentary part of that sandwich is where you should focus right now. What do you comment on? You can either highlight why a source is important or connect it with other sources. This is your chance to point out the answers to the four questions you looked for in your note-taking:</p><ol class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ol" data-offset-key="2u9on-0-0" id="ol_Tahx" name="ol_Tahx"><li id="li_ZItZ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-orderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="2u9on-0-0" name="li_ZItZ">
<p id="p_jBVR" name="p_jBVR" class="">What do researchers agree and disagree about?</p>
</li>
<li id="li_TeNx" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-orderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="o087-0-0" name="li_TeNx">
<p id="p_XxLw" name="p_XxLw" class="">How are researchers narrowing or changing their focus to create new information?</p>
</li>
<li id="li_irGF" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-orderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="ce5u-0-0" name="li_irGF">
<p id="p_wwoQ" name="p_wwoQ" class="">What are each study’s limitations and strengths?</p>
</li>
<li id="li_EJXQ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-orderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="60j6i-0-0" name="li_EJXQ">
<p id="p_qDik" name="p_qDik" class="">What’s the next step in research—what should be studied in the future? (The research gap)</p>
</li>
</ol><p id="p_GFyx" name="p_GFyx" class="">You can think of metacommentary as a sandwich with your name on it. If my student's name were Alisa, here's what an "Alisa sandwich" would look like:</p><p id="p_Cthu" style="text-align: center;" name="p_Cthu" class=""><strong class="">ALISA—SOURCE—ALISA</strong></p><ul id="ul_oLkt" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="9rc49-0-0" name="ul_oLkt"><li id="li_teWp" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="9rc49-0-0" name="li_teWp">
<p id="p_DoLK" name="p_DoLK" class="">First, Alisa starts with a claim about what's happening in the field or about a particular subsection or focus of the field. This could serve as a topic sentence for a paragraph, for example.</p>
</li>
<li id="li_CdoC" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="auuri-0-0" name="li_CdoC">
<p id="p_wiFF" name="p_wiFF" class="">Second, she sets up the source with guiding language like transitions and references to her past points or sources.</p>
</li>
<li id="li_HYBi" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="6mj66-0-0" name="li_HYBi">
<p id="p_JAwH" name="p_JAwH" class="">Third, she talks about the source itself and summarizes pertinent information.</p>
</li>
<li id="li_IAcH" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="bb8ik-0-0" name="li_IAcH">
<p id="p_Yiev" name="p_Yiev" class="">Lastly, Alisa comments on the source and/or connects it to her main point or to next source.</p>
</li>
</ul><p id="p_EtkV" name="p_EtkV" class="">This metacommentary is a lot like the interpretation mentioned in the video at the beginning of this chapter. This type of "sandwich" can occur several times in a paragraph as you synthesize your sources. Here's a sample paragraph from Chris, a Public Health student, (check this) who wrote a paper called "The Causes of a Behavioral Pandemic: Screen-time Addiction and Consequent Depression Among Adolescents." I've bolded the metacommentary Chris had added to guide his readers and to connect his points together.</p><blockquote class="" data-block="true" data-editor="20g9b" data-offset-key="4gn6k-0-0">
<p id="p_XufD" name="p_XufD" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" class=""><strong class="">Even though there have been far fewer studies on adolescents than adults</strong>, adolescent studies have consistently shown that those who are more physically active experience less depressive and associated symptoms, as well as a greater overall state of well-being (Kremer 2014). <strong class="">These studies have also shown that</strong> low levels of vigorous exercise in youth can independently cause depressive symptoms. One longitudinal study revealed that over 30% of children who participate in high levels of screen-time use experience moderate to high levels of depressive symptoms (Kremer 2014). <strong class="">Additionally, another study</strong> of children in the United States demonstrated that those who participated on a sports team were less likely to exceed recommended screen-time limits established by the US Department of Health. <strong class="">This study also demonstrated that</strong> as the number of total physical activity sessions increased among youth, both during free time and at organized events, children were less likely to exceed recommended screen-time limits (Carlson 2010). In this study, children who were more physically active consistently showed lower rates of depression and other emotional disorders. <strong class="">Therefore, evidence across multiple studies suggests that participating in screen-time activity may not be the direct cause of depressive symptoms, but rather the sedentary lifestyle and lack physical activity it causes among youth. With this recent evidence, experts are beginning to search for ways to replace screen-time participation of adolescents with physical activities.</strong></span></p>
</blockquote><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="6g1ke-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="6g1ke-0-0"><span data-offset-key="6g1ke-0-0" class="">Note how the last few sentences of this paragraph consist entirely of metacommentary—points that connect to the bigger picture of Chris's literature review. Also notice how Chris uses transition words and phrases to glue his points together so it doesn't come out of the blue when he brings up a new study. Chris also talks about more than one study in this paragraph, demonstrating his ability to synthesize and not just summarize. Without the metacommentary, it would be much harder to see the connections between the studies and how they fit into the bigger picture. Finally, Chris indicates the implications of these studies and points to what researchers are doing next. This has a dual purpose of reminding readers why this topic is important as well as indicating where he will go in his next paragraph (about physical activities). Metacommentary is powerful!</span></div>
</div><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="r8fk-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="r8fk-0-0"> </div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="r8fk-0-0"><span data-offset-key="r8fk-0-0" class="">Metacommentary takes practice, but you can do it! And it will not only make your points stronger, it will make it easier for your audience to read and understand—which should always be your goal.</span></div>
</div><h4 id="p_tVjs" name="p_tVjs" class=""><strong class="">If You Get Stuck</strong></h4><p id="p_epMI" name="p_epMI" class="">Literature reviews can be hard. If you get stuck, I have a little trick I tell my students. For your first draft, try starting every sentence with "Researchers . . ." I know this seems formulaic, but if you can keep your focus on what particular researchers did or what they agree or disagree on, you'll avoid the most common pitfalls of literature reviews: sounding like a typical argumentative research paper. If your focus is always on what researchers are doing or what they've found, then at the very least you'll stay in the realm of the literature review genre. Later you can go back through and change up your sentence structure, but I've found that this is an easy way for students to get through a first draft.</p><h4 id="p_HYDF" name="p_HYDF" class=""><strong class="">A Quick Word on Verb Tense</strong></h4><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="38r5l" data-offset-key="919fv-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="919fv-0-0">
<div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="3rqfp-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="3rqfp-0-0"><span data-offset-key="3rqfp-0-0" class="">Students often ask about verb tense in relation to literature reviews—do you say that someone "conducted a study" in past tense? But then what if you're saying that "researchers agree" about something? That's in present tense. I use this rule of thumb: if you're talking about something specific that was completed in the past, use the past tense. If you're talking about a current attitude or something currently accepted in a field, then use present tense. For example, if you say that you conducted a review of the literature, then that's over and done with, so you should use the past tense. Or if you want to talk about a particular study that was done, then use the past tense, too. But if you want to say that researchers in general currently agree about something, then you can use the present tense. </span></div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="3rqfp-0-0"> </div>
</div>
<div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="46krd-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="46krd-0-0"><span data-offset-key="46krd-0-0" class="">Things get a little trickier when you talk about what's happened by researchers in the field in general rather than talking about a specific study. For example, if many people have studied hoverboard technology, then you should talk about it in that same tense—they "have studied." That's called the present perfect tense (the verb "to have" + past participle). You don't need to remember the name—just the fact that you can use this tense when you want to say that researchers in the field "have done" something in general or that a review of a topic "has been done." So here's a table based on the work of Feak and Swales (2009) to sum this up:</span></div>
</div>
</div>
</div><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="38r5l" data-offset-key="c1bmg-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="c1bmg-0-0"> </div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="c1bmg-0-0"> </div>
</div><table class="TableBodystyles__Table-sc-4jqrd0-0 jZqVIH"><tbody class=""><tr class="TableRowstyles__Row-z35sgp-0 kgAvIg"><th class="TableCellstyles__HeaderCell-sc-181faeq-1 zjeCQ" scope="col">
<p id="p_wIzw" name="p_wIzw" class="">Tense</p>
<p id="p_AMHN" name="p_AMHN" class=""></p>
</th>
<th class="TableCellstyles__HeaderCell-sc-181faeq-1 zjeCQ" scope="col">
<p id="p_Qbtp" name="p_Qbtp" class="">Reference</p>
<p id="p_WbGy" name="p_WbGy" class=""></p>
</th>
<th class="TableCellstyles__HeaderCell-sc-181faeq-1 zjeCQ" scope="col">
<p id="p_bmvX" name="p_bmvX" class="">Example</p>
<p id="p_vLnK" name="p_vLnK" class=""></p>
</th>
</tr><tr class="TableRowstyles__Row-z35sgp-0 kgAvIg"><td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_vumE" name="p_vumE" class="">Past Tense</p>
<p id="p_oynJ" name="p_oynJ" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_hLgH" name="p_hLgH" class="">A Single Study or Event</p>
<p id="p_yNwo" name="p_yNwo" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_QPDM" name="p_QPDM" class="">McFly (1989) investigated the usefulness of hoverboards in a chase.</p>
<p id="p_RjkT" name="p_RjkT" class=""></p>
</td>
</tr><tr class="TableRowstyles__Row-z35sgp-0 kgAvIg"><td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_wGRR" name="p_wGRR" class="">Present Tense</p>
<p id="p_sdBM" name="p_sdBM" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_yNsM" name="p_yNsM" class="">Generally Accepted Knowledge of the Field</p>
<p id="p_mExt" name="p_mExt" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_rDbQ" name="p_rDbQ" class="">One of the most promising areas of hoverboard technology is the use of electromagnets (Allain, 2015).</p>
<p id="p_sydi" name="p_sydi" class=""></p>
</td>
</tr><tr class="TableRowstyles__Row-z35sgp-0 kgAvIg"><td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_oHVe" name="p_oHVe" class="">Present Perfect Tense</p>
<p id="p_SgYo" name="p_SgYo" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_NPeg" name="p_NPeg" class="">An Area of Inquiry</p>
<p id="p_TGTs" name="p_TGTs" class=""></p>
</td>
<td class="TableCellstyles__DataCell-sc-181faeq-0 ioYwCm">
<p id="p_vmeH" name="p_vmeH" class="">The usefulness of skateboards in a chase has been widely researched (McFly, 1985; McFly, 1989; McFly, 1990).</p>
<p id="p_RBbh" name="p_RBbh" class=""></p>
</td>
</tr></tbody></table><p id="p_fcXx" name="p_fcXx" class=""></p><p id="p_APME" style="text-align: center;" name="p_APME" class="">Verb Tenses to Use in Literature Reviews</p><h3 id="p_Scws" name="p_Scws" class=""><strong class="">Discussion/Conclusion</strong></h3><p id="p_DqvN" name="p_DqvN" class="">Your last section will either be called <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="discussion">discussion</span> or <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="conclusion">conclusion</span> (or will possibly not have a heading depending on your teacher's preferences or the style guide you're following). In an effective Discussion (aka Conclusion) section you should</p><ul id="ul_UiHJ" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="daq7v-0-0" name="ul_UiHJ"><li id="li_DtIU" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="daq7v-0-0" name="li_DtIU">
<p id="p_MGTS" name="p_MGTS" class="">do more than sum up what you have said (though you should do that as well)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_UZFQ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="9ria8-0-0" name="li_UZFQ">
<p id="p_Kjhy" name="p_Kjhy" class="">explain where there are gaps and limitations in the previous research done</p>
</li>
<li id="li_Unqb" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="f72lh-0-0" name="li_Unqb">
<p id="p_agAn" name="p_agAn" class="">indicate recommendations for future research based on those gaps</p>
</li>
</ul><p id="p_RUzv" name="p_RUzv" class="">At the end of this section,</p><ul id="ul_mFzp" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="f6dvr-0-0" name="ul_mFzp"><li id="li_dDwJ" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="f6dvr-0-0" name="li_dDwJ">
<p id="p_oWrh" name="p_oWrh" class="">restate your position (thesis statement)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_YXaa" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="e4oah-0-0" name="li_YXaa">
<p id="p_qqyh" name="p_qqyh" class="">show the implications of your findings</p>
</li>
</ul><h3 id="p_kWKX" name="p_kWKX" class=""><strong class="">References</strong></h3><p id="p_CDQn" name="p_CDQn" class=""><span data-offset-key="d24kb-0-0" class="">You must also include a list of your <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="references">References</span> </span><span data-offset-key="d24kb-2-1" class="">(also known as a Bibliography or Works Cited page depending on the documentation style) showing all the sources you referred to in your paper. Your references page must be in alphabetical order and formatted according to your chosen style guide (see </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://edtechbooks.org/writing/sources" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-nbo" data-unshortened-url="https://edtechbooks.org/writing/sources"><span data-offset-key="d24kb-3-0" class="">Chapter 9: Talking About Sources</span></a><span data-offset-key="d24kb-4-0" class="">).</span></p><h3 id="p_NYLP" name="p_NYLP" class=""><strong class="">Other Elements</strong></h3><p id="p_emcV" name="p_emcV" class=""><span data-offset-key="42kil-0-0" class="">Your teacher might require you to include these other elements in your Literature Review paper. Be sure to follow the format from your style guide</span><span data-offset-key="42kil-0-1" class="">.</span></p><h4 id="p_fBru" name="p_fBru" class=""><strong class="">Title Page</strong></h4><p id="p_yHBN" name="p_yHBN" class="">I've waited until now to talk about titles because it's wise to wait until you have a good draft before you choose a title. Why? Because you often don't know exactly where your paper will go until you've written it out. Your title is your readers' first entry into your paper, so you want it to be interesting and also reflect what's inside. Your title should also include as much information as possible while remaining appropriately short and sweet. For example, the <a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-YhB" data-unshortened-url="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/"><em class="">APA Manual</em></a> recommends not using extraneous words but sticking to the main point of your paper. My student Justin's title follows this model:</p><blockquote class="" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="207im-0-0">
<p id="p_XaVq" name="p_XaVq" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" class="">Implications of Chinese Involvement on Africa's Economy</span></p>
</blockquote><p id="p_Uwne" name="p_Uwne" class="">He basically summarizes his main point in one succinct statement—the ultimate summary. APA would be proud.</p><div class="clearfix"> </div><p id="p_cHeS" name="p_cHeS" class=""></p><blockquote class="" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="d08o1-0-0">
<p id="p_BiMG" name="p_BiMG" class=""></p>
</blockquote><p id="p_iQdc" name="p_iQdc" class=""></p><figure class="col-12 col-md-6 float-md-end ms-md-3"><img class="img-fluid" alt="360px-Someones_Mullet_from_their_Family_Photos_(39958323871).jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_4.jpg" id="img_spBq" name="img_spBq"><figcaption class="">The Mullet. Business in the front, party in the back. Image on <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Someones_Mullet_from_their_Family_Photos_(39958323871).jpg" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-maz" data-unshortened-url="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Someones_Mullet_from_their_Family_Photos_(39958323871).jpg">Wikimedia</a></figcaption></figure><p id="p_EPCZ" name="p_EPCZ" class="">However, depending on your sub-field in the Social Sciences, many scholars like to do what I call a "reverse mullet." As you might know, the rad '80s mullet haircut that's short on top and long in the back has been described as</p><blockquote class="">
<p id="p_zWim" name="p_zWim" class=""><strong class="">The Mullet: Business in the front, party in the back</strong></p>
</blockquote><p id="p_xWka" name="p_xWka" class="">A mullet starts with the serious and ends with the fun. But academic titles often do the reverse: they have an interesting introductory phrase, then a colon, and then the standard, more serious title. That's why I call them the</p><div class="clearfix"> </div><p id="p_pDTX" name="p_pDTX" class=""></p><p id="p_wneC" style="text-align: center;" name="p_wneC" class=""></p><p id="p_aTUp" name="p_aTUp" class=""></p><figure class="col-12 col-md-6 float-md-start me-md-3"><img class="img-fluid" alt="Reverse Mullet.jpg" format="left" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_5.jpg" id="img_fLAb" name="img_fLAb"><figcaption class="">Reverse Mullet: Party in the front, business in the back. Photo by <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/wiedmaier/2068787885/" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-AzUs" data-unshortened-url="https://www.flickr.com/photos/wiedmaier/2068787885/">Weidmaier</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote class="">
<p id="p_rCZa" name="p_rCZa" class=""><strong class="">The Reverse Mullet: Party in the front, Business in back</strong></p>
</blockquote><p id="p_NkNr" name="p_NkNr" class="">A reverse mullet title gets the reader's attention before adding the serious explanation. For example, one of my students named Katelyn wrote her Literature Review on how much high school students' perception of their teachers was influenced by their teachers' apparel. Her title included a Reverse Mullet structure:</p><blockquote class="" data-block="true" data-editor="fnerb" data-offset-key="91dp0-0-0">
<div class="clearfix"> </div>
<p id="p_DCXN" style="text-align: center;" name="p_DCXN" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" class=""><strong class="">Keeping it Class-y: How Formality of Teacher Apparel Affects </strong></span></p>
<p id="p_hyQc" style="text-align: center;" name="p_hyQc" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" class=""><strong class="">Student Perceptions of the Teacher in the Classroom</strong></span></p>
</blockquote><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="9amid" data-offset-key="6ficj-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="6ficj-0-0"><span data-offset-key="6ficj-0-0" class="">Because her field is education (Social Science Teaching), this second type of title structure is appropriate and adds interest. You can talk to your writing teacher or the professors in your major to find out which type of title would be most appropriate for you to use in your field. If you want to just play it safe, stick with a plain title, but know you might be missing a chance to draw your readers in.</span></div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="6ficj-0-0"> </div>
</div><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="9amid" data-offset-key="8moqa-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="8moqa-0-0"><span data-offset-key="8moqa-0-0" class="">What else should go on your title page besides your title?</span></div>
</div><ul id="ul_IDHE" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="7oa6r-0-0" name="ul_IDHE"><li id="li_uktW" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="7oa6r-0-0" name="li_uktW">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="7oa6r-0-0"><span data-offset-key="7oa6r-0-0" class="">Your Name (centered)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_QTaY" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="1fgu0-0-0" name="li_QTaY">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="1fgu0-0-0"><span data-offset-key="1fgu0-0-0" class="">Your Teacher's Name (centered on the next line)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_LYyo" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="90pbh-0-0" name="li_LYyo">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="90pbh-0-0"><span data-offset-key="90pbh-0-0" class="">A Page Number (in the top right corner that's continued throughout the paper)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_UkSe" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="9m9oa-0-0" name="li_UkSe">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="9m9oa-0-0"><span data-offset-key="9m9oa-0-0" class="">Optional: the Name of the School or Department</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_Hfad" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="9h5a-0-0" name="li_Hfad">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="9h5a-0-0"><span data-offset-key="9h5a-0-0" class="">Optional: the Name/Number of Your Course (e.g., English 315)</span></div>
</li>
<li id="li_teGB" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="ek799" data-offset-key="4sp33-0-0" name="li_teGB">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="4sp33-0-0"><span data-offset-key="4sp33-0-0" class="">Optional: the Date</span></div>
</li>
</ul><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="9amid" data-offset-key="fdsmq-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="fdsmq-0-0">Your title and these additions should go in the middle of the page. Of course, your teacher is the best person to ask about formatting requirements and will usually give you clear instructions. If you have questions, ask.</div>
</div><h4 id="p_HGEm" name="p_HGEm" class=""><strong class="">Abstract</strong></h4><p id="p_jCZR" name="p_jCZR" class=""><span data-offset-key="86vim-0-0" class="">You should save writing your abstract until after you've completed your paper because it's a summary of the main points of your paper. You can try writing a preliminary abstract now as a type of outline, but you run the risk of finding out that once you're done with your paper, you actually went in some different directions. My advice is to hold off and wait to write the abstract until the end. You can create a page after the title page where your abstract will go, but to emphasize that you should write this last, we'll wait to cover the details of writing an an abstract until the next section.</span></p><h4 id="p_nbjP" name="p_nbjP" class=""><strong class="">Appendix</strong></h4><p id="p_iQsi" name="p_iQsi" class=""><span data-offset-key="dtnq9-0-0" class="">If you have tables or figures ( or formulas or other data) that are too big to be added inside the text of your paper, you can put them at the end. If you only have one<span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="appendix">Appendix</span></span><span data-offset-key="dtnq9-2-0" class="">, you can call it just that. But if you have more than one, call them Appendix A, Appendix B, etc. and refer to them as such in the text of your paper.</span></p><h4 id="p_qkGE" name="p_qkGE" class=""><strong class="">Tables and Figures</strong></h4><p id="p_pnfJ" name="p_pnfJ" class=""><span data-offset-key="29agf-0-0" class="">One more element that could be helpful to your paper is to include tables and/or figures. You're probably familiar with Tables</span><span data-offset-key="29agf-2-0" class=""> (you know, the boxes with lots of horizontal and vertical cells). A </span><mark class="Rolloverstyles__Anchor-sc-1oh0v9b-0 cKyKhG"><span data-offset-key="29agf-3-0" class="">Figure</span></mark><span data-offset-key="29agf-4-0" class=""> is any type of image, graph, or chart besides a table. You can use tables or figures from your sources as long as you cite them properly. You can also create your own table or figure either from existing data or to explain a concept. See </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://app.tophat.com/e/621930/page/117780834" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-wTBh" data-unshortened-url="https://app.tophat.com/e/621930/page/117780834"><span data-offset-key="29agf-5-0" class="">Chapter 6: Design</span></a><span data-offset-key="29agf-6-0" class=""> for the details of how to create, use, or format tables and figures. Just remember to check your style guide; for example, in APA Format, you need to title and number your tables and figures separately.</span></p><p id="p_FZzQ" name="p_FZzQ" class="">I hope you feel like you have a better sense of the structure for your own Literature Review paper. In the next chapter, we'll talk about how to draft and revise your paper.</p><p id="p_EqWf" name="p_EqWf" class=""></p><h2 id="p_IBUA" name="p_IBUA" class="">12.2 Write an Abstract</h2><p id="p_FJYp" name="p_FJYp" class=""></p><figure class="image"><img class="img-fluid col-12" alt="4k-wallpaper-abstract-abstract-expressionism-abstract-painting-acrylic-paint-art-1563849-pxhere.com.jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_6.jpg" id="img_jQKU" name="img_jQKU"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="9urrn-0-0" class="">We're not talking about this kind of abstract! (</span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://pxhere.com/en/photo/1563849" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-ihL" data-unshortened-url="https://pxhere.com/en/photo/1563849"><span data-offset-key="9urrn-1-0" class="">Public Domain</span></a><span data-offset-key="9urrn-2-0" class="">)</span></figcaption></figure><p id="p_MErv" name="p_MErv" class="">Not <em class="">that</em> kind of abstract! As great as abstract art is, what you need now is the abstract of your paper. (Note: some teacher's won't require an abstract, so you can skip this section in that case.) Why do you think we've saved the abstract for last even though it's the first thing your audience will read (after your title)? You guessed it: it's because the abstract is a summary of everything you've talked about in your paper, so if you haven't written your paper yet, it's pretty hard to summarize it.</p><p id="p_WsSxC" name="p_WsSxC" class="">A lot of students think that the abstract is a <em class="">preview</em> of your paper that simply invites the reader to learn more. But that's not the purpose of the abstract, that's the purpose of the <em class="">Introduction</em>. If your paper were a movie, your abstract would <em class="">not</em> be the movie trailer. A movie trailer is an invitation to see more without giving away too much; that's the point of your <em class="">Introduction</em>. Instead, your abstract would be the movie<em class=""> plot synopsis.</em> It would have a big SPOILER ALERT sign in front of it because in it you want to give away all the punchlines from your paper. In fact, the more you include your most important points or findings, the better. Because readers might only ever read your abstract, you want the most important information there. Then just like you did in your own database searching, they will decide based on the abstract whether they should open your paper and read more details. Your job is to make sure they have the best information to do that.</p><p id="p_qRVY" name="p_qRVY" class=""><span data-offset-key="9jljh-0-0" class="">An abstract has a few main parts that mirror the parts of your paper but in miniature. First, in 1-2 sentences, you should introduce the topic, its importance, and the problem or question you tried to answer. Then you should succinctly explain your methods (database searching) and the scope of your project. The last and largest part should consist of your main findings such as the main areas of inquiry where researchers are congregating. You should include the major strengths and limitations (gaps) you found in your review. Finally, you should explain any implications of your study and suggest where future research should go. See? A miniature paper. It should be so miniature, that the </span><a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-YhB" data-unshortened-url="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/"><em class="">APA Manual</em></a><span data-offset-key="9jljh-0-2" class=""> says an abstract should not exceed 250 words. At the end, you can also list a few Keywords to make it easy to search for your paper on databases.</span></p><p id="p_Qyxq" name="p_Qyxq" class="">To solidify your understanding of how to write an abstract, watch this 3-minute video from the University of Melbourne that takes you through a good example. Try not to get distracted by their awesome Australian accents.</p><p id="p_sLzc" name="p_sLzc" class=""></p><div class="youtube-container" data-bs-toggle="modal" data-src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/uFs-3uJDVu4?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" data-bs-target="#youtube-modal"><img class="youtube img-fluid" src="https://img.youtube.com/vi/uFs-3uJDVu4/hqdefault.jpg" data-youtube-id="uFs-3uJDVu4" id="img_MPsh" name="img_MPsh" data-youtube-id="uFs-3uJDVu4" src-ok="1" alt="Image preview of a YouTube video"><div class="youtube-overlay"><img src="https://open.byu.edu/images/youtube-icon.png" alt="" id="img_xVXh" name="img_xVXh" class=""></div></div><a href="https://www.youtube.com/embed/uFs-3uJDVu4?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" target="_blank" class="d-block text-center youtube-link" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-dITC" data-unshortened-url="https://www.youtube.com/embed/uFs-3uJDVu4?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1"><small class="text-muted">Watch on YouTube <span class="display-url pdf-only">https://open.byu.edu/-dITC</span></small></a><p id="p_VLCE" name="p_VLCE" class=""></p><p id="p_MwTy" name="p_MwTy" class="">Now if you would like more details, you can refer to this explanation.</p><p id="p_ekEa" name="p_ekEa" class=""></p><p id="p_XgEK" name="p_XgEK" class=""><iframe class="Iframestyles__Iframe-accts1-2 gjjnFa" style="width: 100%; height: 400px;" src="https://services.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/471274/Writing_an_Abstract_Update_051112.pdf" data-mce-fragment="1"></iframe></p><h2 id="p_TxCr" name="p_TxCr" class="">12.3 The Real Last Step: Revise (and Revise and Revise)</h2><figure class="image"><img class="img-fluid col-12" alt="pine-watt-unsplash.jpg" format="center" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_7.jpg" id="img_KXMF" name="img_KXMF"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="cm3i3-0-0" class="">Revision means re-vision. Photo by </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://unsplash.com/@pinewatt"><span data-offset-key="cm3i3-1-0" class="">pine watt</span></a><span data-offset-key="cm3i3-2-0" class=""> on Unsplash</span></figcaption></figure><p id="p_VMXX" name="p_VMXX" class="">The best writers revise (and revise and revise). Think back to <a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://app.tophat.com/e/621930/page/122792560" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-KIv" data-unshortened-url="https://app.tophat.com/e/621930/page/122792560"> Chapter 3: Writing Processes </a> and the section on Revision. You need to think like your audience, which means you have to get out of your own head and think mindfully. One way to do this is to <em class="">revise with purpose</em> or in other words, with specific goals in mind.</p><p id="p_mddW" name="p_mddW" class="">You can't revise without a decent draft, so don't blow off the first draft deadline. The better your first draft, the better your paper will be in the end because you'll have enough time to really look at your paper. Actually re-look at your paper, or in other words, re-vise. Get it? Re-vision?</p><p id="p_NkDE" name="p_NkDE" class="">So how can you get out of your own head? Two ways: people and levels. The first way to get a fresh perspective is audience-oriented revision: peer review, teacher conferences, writing center appointments, and other outside feedback from real, live people.</p><h3 id="p_wzZG" name="p_wzZG" class=""><strong class="">Get Feedback!</strong></h3><p id="p_HLGd" name="p_HLGd" class=""></p><figure class="image"><img class="col-12 float-md-start col-md-6 mb-md-2 me-md-3 ms-md-0" alt="jon-tyson-420512-unsplash.jpg" format="left" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_8.jpg" id="img_aZaT" name="img_aZaT"><figcaption class="">Seek feedback! Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jontyson" class="">Jon Tyson</a> on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><p id="p_Ctdh" name="p_Ctdh" class="">When you find out how other people react to your paper, it will give you invaluable perspective into what's working and what's not. This is feedback and is extremely valuable. Your teacher should help you do these kinds of peer reviews and revisions in class.</p><p id="p_gaZe" name="p_gaZe" class=""><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-0" class="">Feedback can also come from anyone—friends, teachers, relatives, Writing Center tutors, roommates—just be sure to choose someone you trust who also knows about good writing and won't hesitate to tell you where you can improve. I don't know your grandma, but if she's the type of grandma who will tell you your paper is great no matter what's in it because you're just so nice, then run away! Okay, don't really run away from your grandma—she's probably very loving and supportive. Give her a hug instead. However, </span><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-1" class="">don't </span><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-2" class="">give your paper to your grandma to critique in that case. </span><em class="">My</em><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-4" class=""> grandma is actually a fantastic writer and wouldn't be afraid to tell me where I can improve. </span><em class="">Do </em><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-6" class="">give your paper to someone like </span><em class="">my</em><span data-offset-key="fgprl-0-8" class=""> grandma.</span></p><blockquote class="">
<p id="p_sTPZ" name="p_sTPZ" class=""><span style="color: #169179;" data-offset-key="fgprl-0-8" class="">Here's a tip: Most universities have a Writing Center where you can take your paper to a Writing Tutor for help and feedback for free. Do it! It's free! And they can even meet with you online.</span></p>
</blockquote><p id="p_DIrr" name="p_DIrr" class="">We're lucky at BYU that we even have our very own Social Science-specific Writing Center: the <a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://fhsswriting.byu.edu/"> FHSS Writing Lab</a>. They know Literature Reviews well and can help you with any stage of the writing process from selecting a topic to citing sources to synthesis. If you have more general writing questions (or if you need an appointment after 5pm), you can also go to the main <a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="http://writingcenter.byu.edu/"> BYU Research & Writing Center</a>. They also offer online appointments. If you're not on our campus, look up your school's writing center.</p><p id="p_Mzvg" name="p_Mzvg" class="">As an undergrad, my husband didn't start out with the best writing skills, so he used to take his papers to the BYU Writing Center over and over and over. I think they made the rule that you can only go once a day because of him. And guess what? It helped! His grades went up! That was his secret to success that I'm passing on to you. Your teacher doesn't have time to personally meet with each student over and over and over, but the Writing Tutors are literally paid to do just that. Well, maybe keep your visits to only one per day, but you get what I mean. Take advantage! Make an appointment right now! Did I mention that it's free? </p><p id="p_zmXi" name="p_zmXi" class=""><span data-offset-key="612mr-0-0" class="">If you need more motivation to just do it, watch </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXsQAXx_ao0" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-NrAL" data-unshortened-url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXsQAXx_ao0"><span data-offset-key="612mr-1-0" class="">this "motivational" video</span></a><span data-offset-key="612mr-2-0" class=""> by Shia Le Boeuf.</span></p><h3 id="h3_qbCQ" name="h3_qbCQ" class=""><span data-offset-key="612mr-2-0" class="">Revise by Levels</span></h3><p id="p_WWZe" name="p_WWZe" class="">The second way to improve your paper is to go through a layered revision process focusing on global and then local issues. <span data-offset-key="ednr5-0-0" class="">As you re-see your paper, take my advice and tackle <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="global_issues">Global Revision</span> </span><span data-offset-key="ednr5-2-0" class="">before you focus on <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="local_issues">Local Revision</span>.</span><span data-offset-key="ednr5-4-0" class=""> What do I mean by that? Let me tell you a quick story.</span></p><p id="p_xpjD" name="p_xpjD" class=""><strong class="">A Revision Story Involving Cats</strong></p><p id="p_zbDh" name="p_zbDh" class="">When my family and I were moving to our town, we looked at a lot of houses online. We fell in love with a beautiful old house that had been totally renovated but was selling at a shockingly low price. When we finally visited the house with our realtor, we discovered why it had been on the market for so long: it smelled like cat pee. Like really, really smelled. It turns out the house had been occupied by what many people would call a "crazy cat lady"—an older woman who lived with at least 50 cats. Then tragically, a fire completely destroyed the house (I'm pretty sure the woman and her cats survived).</p><p id="p_QvMp" name="p_QvMp" class=""></p><figure class="image"><img class="img-fluid col-12" alt="jessica-furtney-244838-unsplash.jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_9.jpg" id="img_Hhwa" name="img_Hhwa"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="dnj1f-0-0" class="">To protect the innocent, this is not the infamous cat house but is close to what it looked like. Photo by </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://unsplash.com/@jessicamaephotographyga" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-bLk" data-unshortened-url="https://unsplash.com/@jessicamaephotographyga"><span data-offset-key="dnj1f-1-0" class="">Jessica Furtney</span></a><span data-offset-key="dnj1f-2-0" class=""> on Unsplash</span></figcaption></figure><p id="p_yFmC" name="p_yFmC" class="">The home owner used $400,000 of insurance money to beautifully restore the house. They rebuilt the intricate wooden staircase, restored the stately crown molding, installed lush carpet, and added upgrades to a gorgeous kitchen. The only problem was that they did their restoration in the wrong order—they took care of the <em class="">local issues</em> of paint color and carpet thickness while ignoring the more <em class="">global issue</em> of the smell. Eventually, they had to rip up all their work in the basement in order to treat the floor with a special enzyme that combated cat urine. If they'd just treated the cat smell first, then they could have saved themselves thousands of dollars, hours of work, and could have sold their house for a much higher price.</p><p id="p_KgTU" name="p_KgTU" class=""><strong class="">The Moral of the Story</strong></p><figure class="col-12 col-md-6 float-md-start me-md-3"><img class="img-fluid" alt="andrew-umansky-unsplash.jpg" format="left" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_10.jpg" id="img_xXqC" name="img_xXqC"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="1cs79-0-0" class="">Always get rid of the cat pee (global issues) first! Photo by </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://unsplash.com/@angur"><span data-offset-key="1cs79-1-0" class="">Andrew Umansky</span></a><span data-offset-key="1cs79-2-0" class=""> on Unsplash</span></figcaption></figure><p id="p_oHdg" name="p_oHdg" class=""><span data-offset-key="3q2op-0-0" class="">What does all this have to do with revision? You've got it—treat the <em class="">g</em></span><em class="">lobal issues </em><span data-offset-key="3q2op-0-2" class="">first! Get rid of the cat pee! Don't worry about </span><em class="">local issues</em><span data-offset-key="3q2op-0-4" class=""> like flowery language or sentences that connect perfectly to each other if you're just going to have to completely renovate that section later. Work on the </span><em class="">global issues</em><span data-offset-key="3q2op-0-6" class=""> like ideas, logical order, and evidence first and wait until those are intact before focusing on the details. Put another way, whole-paper and paragraph-level revisions should come before sentence-level and word-level changes.</span></p><p id="p_rTQw" name="p_rTQw" class="">As a final gift, fantastic BYU Family Science professor Julie Haupt offers the following path for doing four purposeful revisions—two global revisions and two local revisions. If you really want to improve your literature review, follow these steps.</p><div class="clearfix"> </div><h3 id="p_xPZr" name="p_xPZr" class=""><strong class="">GLOBAL REVISION—The Forest</strong></h3><figure class="col-12 col-md-6 float-md-end ms-md-3"><img class="img-fluid" alt="Forest.jpg" format="right" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_11.jpg" id="img_JRDk" name="img_JRDk"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="835qe-0-0" class="">First, look at the forest, not the trees. Photo by</span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://unsplash.com/@landscapeplaces" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-ToVK" data-unshortened-url="https://unsplash.com/@landscapeplaces"><span data-offset-key="835qe-1-0" class=""> Frederico Bottos</span></a><span data-offset-key="835qe-2-0" class=""> on Unsplash</span></figcaption></figure><h4 id="p_HGbc" name="p_HGbc" class=""><strong class="">Level 1: Structural Review (Global)</strong></h4><p id="p_WZiH" name="p_WZiH" class=""><strong class="">Purpose: </strong>The structural review examines the document as a whole to see if all requirements are met and the document’s organization is sound.</p><p id="p_aiUX" name="p_aiUX" class=""><strong class="">Meet Assignment Requirements.</strong> Ask yourself if your paper meets all the requirements of the assignment? Look at your structure and make sure you have all necessary sections such as the following:</p><ul id="ul_jEgQ" class="public-DraftStyleDefault-ul" data-offset-key="489te-0-0" name="ul_jEgQ"><li id="li_iwHb" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-reset public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="489te-0-0" name="li_iwHb">
<p id="p_sDhi" name="p_sDhi" class="">Title Page</p>
</li>
<li id="li_AvzI" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="7vvqt-0-0" name="li_AvzI">
<p id="p_qysX" name="p_qysX" class="">Abstract</p>
</li>
<li id="li_Mfpr" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="dtpuf-0-0" name="li_Mfpr">
<p id="p_GYaD" name="p_GYaD" class="">Introduction (with Thesis Statement and/or Organizing Statement)</p>
</li>
<li id="li_Qmhj" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="fgc02-0-0" name="li_Qmhj">
<p id="p_DvLE" name="p_DvLE" class="">Body with Headings</p>
</li>
<li id="li_rdyT" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="4ssvk-0-0" name="li_rdyT">
<p id="p_nGTV" name="p_nGTV" class="">Conclusion/Discussion</p>
</li>
<li id="li_hMwP" class="common-editor__text--list public-DraftStyleDefault-unorderedListItem public-DraftStyleDefault-depth0 public-DraftStyleDefault-listLTR" data-block="true" data-editor="11jp7" data-offset-key="6pbnd-0-0" name="li_hMwP">
<p id="p_oVYk" name="p_oVYk" class="">References</p>
</li>
</ul><p id="p_UgSV" name="p_UgSV" class=""><strong class="">Include a Thesis and an Organizing Statement.</strong> Does the current version of the thesis statement match the tone, scope, and organization of the body text? Does an organizing statement after the thesis introduce the major topics and the order they will appear in the body (e.g., “In this review, I will first discuss . . . then . . . and finally . . .)</p><p id="p_qLSH" name="p_qLSH" class=""><strong class="">Use Headings.</strong> Is the body text subdivided in a logical way with evidence-based information located in appropriate sections? Are the major sections roughly symmetrical (in terms of length)? Are the headings brief, yet descriptive? If subheadings are used, does the major section contain at least two? Are all levels of headings separated by text?</p><h4 id="p_qZRF" name="p_qZRF" class=""><strong class="">Level 2 (Global): Paragraph/Logic Review</strong></h4><p id="p_yiDf" name="p_yiDf" class=""><strong class="">Purpose:</strong> The Paragraph/Logic Review is designed to review each paragraph for cohesion and compliance to the CEC (Claim-Evidence-Commentary) format.</p><p id="p_hDJL" name="p_hDJL" class=""><strong class="">Sequence Paragraphs Effectively.</strong> When reading only the first sentence of each paragraph, does the logical pattern of the paper emerge? Do the claims made in these topic sentences coordinate well with the thesis of the paper?</p><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="7rn3l" data-offset-key="5ung3-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="5ung3-0-0"><span data-offset-key="5ung3-0-0" class=""><strong class="">Check Topic Sentences and Cohesion.</strong> </span><span data-offset-key="5ung3-0-1" class="">Does the topic sentence or claim provide an effective overview of the information that is located in the paragraph? Is the claim supported by several points of synthesized evidence, rather than a single study? Does each paragraph seem well directed and cohesive?  Do the sentences build one upon another within the paragraph in a logical way?</span></div>
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="5ung3-0-0"> </div>
</div><div class="common-editor__text" data-block="true" data-editor="7rn3l" data-offset-key="3a7sm-0-0">
<div class="public-DraftStyleDefault-block public-DraftStyleDefault-ltr" data-offset-key="3a7sm-0-0"><strong class="">Evaluate Paragraph Length.</strong><span data-offset-key="3a7sm-0-1" class=""> Are any paragraphs too long (longer than approximately ½ page)? Are any paragraphs too short (approximately three sentences or less)? Do paragraphs transition well from one to the next and use transitional words to connect ideas?</span></div>
</div><h3 id="p_ffBa" name="p_ffBa" class=""><strong class="">LOCAL REVISION—The Tree</strong></h3><figure class="col-12"><img class="img-fluid" alt="lumber-84678_640.jpg" format="center" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_12.jpg" id="img_PcXQ" name="img_PcXQ"><figcaption class=""><span data-offset-key="daid2-0-0" class="">In Local Revision, you'll pay more attention to the details of the "tree." Photo by </span><a class="Linkstyles__StyledLink-va99s-0 jrRAFs" href="https://www.publicdomainpictures.net/en/view-image.php?image=24137&picture=tree-stump-texture" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-iCA" data-unshortened-url="https://www.publicdomainpictures.net/en/view-image.php?image=24137&picture=tree-stump-texture"><span data-offset-key="daid2-1-0" class="">Petr Kratochvil</span></a><span data-offset-key="daid2-2-0" class=""> on Pixabay</span></figcaption></figure><h4 id="p_vFni" name="p_vFni" class=""><strong class="">Level 3 (Local): APA Formatting Review</strong></h4><p id="p_FpvQ" name="p_FpvQ" class=""><strong class="">Purpose: </strong>The APA Formatting Review is designed to make sure all APA conventions are explicitly followed to help the paper reflect a high level of professionalism.</p><p id="p_UMhc" name="p_UMhc" class=""><strong class="">Check Document Formatting.</strong> Do the title page, abstract, body text, and reference page appear in the correct page formatting as required? (Use the <a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/" class="" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-YhB" data-unshortened-url="https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition/"><em class="">APA Manual</em></a> if you have questions.)</p><p id="p_Nmjm" name="p_Nmjm" class=""><strong class="">Examine the Reference List Closely.</strong> Are all references in the reference list ordered alphabetically? Is the reference list double spaced entirely (with no extra gaps between paragraphs)? Are all references (e.g., journal articles, internet resources, or books) listed in the correct format? Is every reference on the reference list cited at least once in the body and does each in-text citation have a corresponding reference in the reference list?</p><p id="p_GDLm" name="p_GDLm" class=""><strong class="">Make a Final Check of the In-Text Citations.</strong> Is all information properly cited with an in-text citation when needed? Do all in-text citations include the year next to the author(s)? When more than one citation is listed within parentheses are they separated by semi-colons and ordered alphabetically by first author’s last name? If included in parentheses, do studies with multiple authors use ampersands ("&" rather than the word "and") before listing the last author?</p><p id="p_eCWK" name="p_eCWK" class=""><strong class="">Use “et al.” Correctly.</strong> If a study has three or more authors, do you include only the first author’s last name + et al. + publication year in in-text citations? Do you include all authors up to 20 in the References page? For any publications with 21 or more authors, do you include the first 19 authors' name, then insert an ellipsis ( . . . ), and then the last author's name? </p><h4 id="p_VIDG" name="p_VIDG" class=""><strong class="">Level 4 (Local): Finishing Review</strong></h4><p id="p_qZyK" name="p_qZyK" class=""><strong class="">Purpose: </strong>The Finishing Review is an opportunity to look closely at sentence construction, language, <span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="hedge">hedging</span> (qualifying statements), and grammar/punctuation.</p><p id="p_ELUj" name="p_ELUj" class=""><strong class="">Review Phrasing with a Read-Aloud Session.</strong> Read your paper aloud. Since having to read a sentence twice to get its meaning or “tripping over” phrasing can be an indication of awkward construction, are all sentences easily read aloud? Are any sentences so long that they have become difficult to comprehend, but could be split without changing the meaning?</p><p id="p_bqZV" name="p_bqZV" class=""><strong class="">Use Non-Biased, Non-Absolute Language.</strong> Do all references to people comply with the “people first” designation and avoid inappropriate uses of terms for various groups? Are the findings and summary statements in the review properly “<span class="glossary-link" role="button" data-anchor-name="hedge">hedged</span>”?</p><p id="p_chXR" name="p_chXR" class=""><strong class="">Check Punctuation and Grammar.</strong> Are all commas, semicolons, colons, hyphens, and other punctuation used correctly throughout the document (including the reference page)? Are common grammar mistakes, such as parallelism, subject-verb agreement, incorrect misuse of pronouns, and other grammatical issues corrected?</p><h3 id="p_thcZ" name="p_thcZ" class=""><strong class="">Conclusion</strong></h3><p id="p_KPkP" name="p_KPkP" class="">I know Literature Reviews can be daunting, but I hope that after reading this chapter you feel better prepared to tackle this bodacious writing assignment. As you practice writing, you'll find that it'll get easier and easier until it's as intuitive as riding a hoverboard.</p><figure class="image"><img class="img-fluid col-12" alt="25343417969_5611ed1386_z.jpg" format="center" src="https://open.byu.edu//content_images/writing/xtJA_13.jpg" id="img_cYIt" name="img_cYIt"><figcaption class="">Writing a Literature Review can be as easy as riding a hoverboard.</figcaption></figure><h3 id="p_jnHn" name="p_jnHn" class="">*Bonus Video</h3><p id="p_FATK" name="p_FATK" class="">If you're still confused or would like more guidance on writing a literature review, here is an optional 25-minute video that thoroughly goes through the entire process of writing a literature review. As an extra bonus, it's made by Michael Paye from the University of Dublin who has an awesome Irish accent. Enjoy!</p><figure class="image"><div class="youtube-container" data-bs-toggle="modal" data-src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/ouY2FH0BKkQ?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" data-bs-target="#youtube-modal"><img class="img-fluid col-12" src="https://img.youtube.com/vi/ouY2FH0BKkQ/maxresdefault.jpg" data-youtube-id="ouY2FH0BKkQ" id="img_BFPB" name="img_BFPB" data-youtube-id="ouY2FH0BKkQ" src-ok="1" alt="Image preview of a YouTube video"><div class="youtube-overlay"><img src="https://open.byu.edu/images/youtube-icon.png" alt="" id="img_SXgY" name="img_SXgY" class=""></div></div><a href="https://www.youtube.com/embed/ouY2FH0BKkQ?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1" target="_blank" class="d-block text-center youtube-link" data-shortened-url="https://open.byu.edu/-wDdC" data-unshortened-url="https://www.youtube.com/embed/ouY2FH0BKkQ?autoplay=1&rel=0&showinfo=0&modestbranding=1"><small class="text-muted">Watch on YouTube <span class="display-url pdf-only">https://open.byu.edu/-wDdC</span></small></a><figcaption class="">https://youtu.be/ouY2FH0BKkQ</figcaption></figure><textarea data-text_entry-id="improvements" id="improvements" class="text-entry form-control">